|This blog entry is really for beginners. If you are happy with what you are accomplishing just skip this entry. But otherwise if you are the person who reads the blogs, you might have some tools, but finds the road to furnitureville insurmountable, hopefully, this blog entry might be a little energizing.|
A short digression:
When I am not pondering and pontificating about tools, and I am usually trying to get 3 squares on the table for my family. In the past 4 years my cooking has been greatly influenced by the following two books and a website.
Cheater BBQ: Barbecue Anytime, Anywhere, in Any Weather by Mindy Merrell and R. B. Quinn
Which gave me a great solution on how to get that great BBQ flavor in a NYC apartment.
Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day by Jeff Hertzberg and Zoe Francois enabled me to make home made rye bread, better than I can buy, for almost no work. (the book has tons of great recipes but if I can make rye bread why bother with anything else?)
And a web site: www.vahrehvah.com. I not only learned how to cook Indian food I learned a basic casual attitude towards recipes that really liberated my cooking and cut down on the time I spent making stuff. His videos are great and really encouraging and he has the simplest, least expensive kitchen setup of any chef I have ever seen on TV.
That being said finding the Cheater BBQ book made me want to make cheater pastrami - pastrami being one of my favorite foods and that was a fun adventure you can read about here.
Now the impetus for writing this blog entry was the publication of my recipe for cheater pastrami but as I thought about this I realized that there is a woodworking lesson to learn from this.
It's easy to be paralyzed by perfection.
A lot of people feel that unless they have the perfect tool they can't do anything. Instead of working with what they have and practicing technique, they agonize and stay in a state of paralysis waiting until they have cut the perfect dovetail in a practice piece with the perfect saw; set up a dedicated sharpening center, and built the perfect shop.
It's paralyzing and discouraging. Also I bet you get a lot of comments from your family about when you will finish anything.
To start building furniture you need the following things:
A place to work.
Some sort of table to use as a workbench
A half dozen tools
A way to sharpen them
An idea of what you want to make
Everything else is frosting. Now I admit I'm part of the problem - I want to sell you the perfect dovetail saw or mortise chisel and now a veneer saw. Hey it's my job - I'm more to be pitied than judged. My tools will make making things easier, and as your work gets better, better tools make the job less frustrating and more productive. So yes you might want to buy some nice tools in the future.
But for now don't let the lack of tools paralyze you. The trick when you are beginning is to figure out what you want to make, design the item to work within the range of what skills and tools you have and then go for it. The big secret of woodworking is that anyone, even rankest beginner, who manages to bring anything out of the workshop into the light of day is hailed as a craftsman by people who have never tried to make stuff. They won't see the flaws you see. They will complain about the color and the size, but they won't notice the gaps in joinery (especially after you fill them with wax). They will cheer you on to the next project. I promise. And practice will make it perfect.
The way to learn to saw straight, the way to plane accurately, sharpen, and etc. is to practice it, and pay attention to what you are practicing so you learn from your mistakes. Complicated projects can be broken down into manageable pieces, and with each project, you will get better. Here's just one idea to get you making sawdust: The first project in The Joiner and Cabinetmaker is a nailed together packing crate. You don't need many tools to make it. It's only marginally useful when it's done, but if you are learning to use tools I can't imagine a better use of your time than cutting up and nailing together a box. Go for it. It's easier than you think and it will push you forward.
Join the conversation
I'm going to have try this. Thanks!
thanks for the great blogs! I always enjoy your thoughts and ideas!
for the step up from a nailed together box to your first dovetailed box. I started with Five Minutes a Day much like I started with an old stanely no. 5 and set of Marples chisels. Thanks for the Cheater Bar-b-que tip ;)
BTW, I agree on the coriander tip!
PS - I will have to start following the Cheater site and pick up the Artisan Bread book... I'm responsible for the three squares in my house too!
Awesome! I received the bread book you mentioned for xmas and am excited to try it. I am really psyched about the indian website. We love indian food but have not made it at home and also received some indian spices for xmas. Very timely. I also appreciate the advice about just building something. I am occasionally paralyzed by wanting to make things perfectly the first time and have been transitioning to hand tools. Excellent advice and post. Thanks a million.
And I'd love to hear what your idea is of those "half dozen tools". I'm still in the "use the dining room table with a bench hook" stage of woodworking, so my curiousity has a reason.
Finally, for other novice woodworkers, may I refer you to the "I Can Do That" projects over at the Popular Woodworking site? Some are kind of silly, but others are quite nice, teach real woodworking skills, and can be made with hand tools.
It doesn't matter which 1/2 dozen tools you have - build what you have tools for. Don't buy tools until you actually need them for a specific task. Slowly a full shop will develop.
If you read the the "Joiner and Cabinet Maker" you can see that the actual number of tools that are used for the projects are tiny. Even in a fully equipped shop - molding planes, and other less used tools belonged to the master and the journeymen and apprentices had very very few tools.
As I continue to learn to use tools I find myself using fewer and fewer of them but the fewer I do use are used more skillfully and are working better than when I started. (I actually own pretty much everything ever invented) Where the fully stocked toolbox comes in is for specialized operations that one does infrequently. For the day in and day out work the actual toolkit is pretty small. I'm starting to write a bunch of how to blogs which specially try to avoid using lot of specialized tools and rely on practice to get good results. So stay tuned.
I most certainly know about the "I can do that" series in pop wood - it's a great series.
I have a huge library and I am still constantly learning new stuff on the web, in books, and in new sources that come to light (Although sometimes what I am learning is that not every NEW IDEA is a better idea). In addition to study the great partner in teaching is practice, and practice makes perfect. And remember to go out and look at as much great furniture in your area as you can find.
I've been woodworking off and on for 15 years or so and started in MS/HS shop classes. It's only been the last 4-5 years that I've really learned anything, but more importantly I spent the last 10-15 years saying 'I need this power tool, I need that power tool - I really can't do much with what I've got' but of course, money was always an issue. Well, the last few years I think a replacement Dremel is the only powered tool I've gotten - and nearly everything else was old/used hand tools. BUT, and more importantly - I learned how to use what I have and it's rare for me to use a power tool now - and I've finished a lot more projects the last 2-3 years than I did the entire 40 years of my life prior to that :D
That's not to say I don't salivate over the lovely new tools (specifically hand tools) that are adorning various sites/retailers, etc.) and money isn't getting any better so my poor old blue handles, and that #5 with half the jappaning gone will likely remain my babies for a while and I dont' have many complaints!
Now if only I could get my technique in stone :P
Right on the mark! To all woodworkers-in-waiting: make something! The point is to make it so that it has meaning to you - however modest the project, however sparse your tool set, and however limited your skills.
Joel, if I made add a few thoughts on this topic, here they are:
Thanks for your referral of the cheater website.